Every time I hear that line, I keep thinking how I'd even prefer if the line was "and nobody remembers their name two weeks after they do."
While I'm on the topic of lines that miss the mark, I'm annoyed at the closing of "In Your Lap," in which he's "dreaming of touching your arm." Who dreams of touching someone's arm? The line could have easily been "I'm dreaming of being in your arms," which I think is much prettier.